"That has always been my issue with them (outside of S1). Lucas isn’t allowed to just fall for her, he had to love her as a kid. He had to be told over and over that they were true love always. The worst part was that he was in love with Brooke and Lindsay. It was real. It was pure. It wasn’t perfect but nothing is and then we have to hear them say that they were footnotes in the LP story. No. Sorry you don’t give us kisses in the rain, dreams of a future together in college AND BROOKE BEING AT HIS SIDE WHEN HIS DREAMS COME TRUE (3 TIMES: BASKETBALL CHAMPIONSHIP, HIS NOVEL BEING PUBLISHED, THE BIRTH OF HIS KID) then tell me it was nothing. I will never believe that Peyton isn’t Lucas’ fallback chick."